Lying in bed on Saturday morning listening to the radio I was just a little amused by the news that a German company has been bugging our wheelie-bins. It transpires that it’s not the Germans that are keeping an eye on us, but our very own councils who requested that the electronic bugging devices be installed by German companies. So I went out to have a good look at our wheelie bin this morning, and lo and behold, we’ve been bugged! This is a picture of our bug.
Apparently more that 500,000 British wheelie bins have been secretly bugged, and now the news is out, what do people think about it? Well it seems that although some of us have reacted initially with amusement and then wary acceptance, others are taking this matter far more seriously indeed. Here are some excerpts from the thisislondon.co.uk’s article on the bugging of our bins and a selection of public comments submitted in reaction to the article:
The official reason for the bugs is to ‘improve efficiency’ and settle disputes between neighbours over wheelie-bin ownership. But experts say the technology is actually intended to enable councils to impose fines on householders who exceed limits on the amount of non-recyclable waste they put out. New powers for councils to do this are expected to be introduced by the Government shortly.
But the revelation that the bins have already been altered ignited a ‘Bin Brother’ row over privacy and taxes. Conservative MP Andrew Pelling said burglars could hack into the computer system to see if sudden reductions in waste at individual households meant the owners were on holiday and the property empty.
He said: ‘This is nothing more than a spy in the bin and I don’t think even the old Soviet Union made such an intrusion into people’s personal lives.
‘It is Big Brother gone mad. I think a more British way of doing things is to seek to persuade people rather than spy on them.’
If I find one on my bin, I shall
1) Cease all recycling
2) Take a black & decker to said device
- Peter Chalmers, Oxford
As with many people in urban areas and London especially, I live in a block of flats with communial bins. If one of the residents insists on putting recycleable rubbish in the normal bins, what will they do? Will all the residents be rounded up and interrogated until the culprit owns up?
I’m off to wrap my bin in tinfoil.
- Neil Marklew, London
It occurs to me that now might be the time to form Anti-neighbourhood Watches with the aim of meeting once a week with your wheelie bin and swoping it with another member at random, thus at one masterfull stroke negating all the data collection.
This doesn’t stop them collecting the data, just that all their time and effort will be wasted as the data collected will be useless.
- Quantox, Wokingham, UK
Infringement of Civil Liberty? Still trying to fathom that out but to say I’m furious is an understatement.
I fail to understand why bugging my Green (paper) bin and my Grey (plastics) bin will help the council determine how much non-recyclable waste I am producing.
I have no concern over collecting metrics regarding waste but I am very concerned about the sneaky, underhand method used by my council to determine MY waste output.
- Peter S, Crewe and Nantwich, Cheshire
Again I’m finding some of this amusing. I recycle as much as possible and try where I can to reduce non-recyclable waste, everyone else should be doing this too and if they aren’t there should be consequences. I don’t like the idea of robbers hacking into the council’s website to find out when I’m away on holiday, but, quite frankly, it seems quite unlikely. What do you think?
UPDATE: I’ve been thinking about this for a while now, and my final word on the subject is: I’m far more scared of global warming than I am of having my "civil liberties" infringed upon by a council who is trying to encourage recycling.