Switching to natural and eco-friendly toiletries and cosmetics has been a breeze, apart from the underarm deodorant department, where things haven’t been breeze-like at all. I just don’t seem to be able to find a natural product that does what it says on the bottle. Are my expectations too high? Most commercial deodorants available are actually anti-perspirants, while natural deodorants are just that, deodorants. Is this why the one works and the other doesn’t work as well? I’ve read that there may be a (as yet unproven) link between anti-perspirants and cancer, as well as a link between aluminium in odour control products and an increase in Alzheimers. What to do?
I have tried both the crystal and liquid form of PitRok with disappointing results, Avalon Organics Peppermint Deodorant, Bionsen, Weleda and two different Tom’s of Maine flavours (these seemed to work best until I got a rash). While I still have a few tricks up my sleeve, I seem to be running out of ideas and thinking about going back to using Dove anti-perpirant, which has been my old faithful for years.
Over the next couple of weeks I am going to be trying: drinking more water, baking powder and lemon mixed into a paste and plastered into pits, and a Lush deodorant. I’ll report back on these, but in the meantime, if anyone has any foolproof, healthy, natural and eco-friendly eau de control ideas, I’d be very pleased indeed.












Hi there
Found this a few days ago and am really enjoying reading about your experiences - and some of the blogs you link to are also excellent so thank you.
I tried to post a comment the other day but couldn’t, so trying again now.
This is an interesting question and one I’ll be interested to hear your further experiences on. I do try hard to buy eco products and am slowly replacing “conventional” products with better choices. Deodorant is one thing it’s hard to get right even without taking the eco issue into account! I use Rexona which is a Lever Faberge product, not available here (Ireland) but I stock up when in France or Germany. Will try an eco one next time I need to replace it and let you know how I get on.
Just re: the reported links between conventional anti-perspirants and cancer, I’m fairly sure these were very convincing emails circulated a few years ago and later proven to be of the urban myth variety. If you check some of the urban legend web site you’d probably find the information and how it has been refuted. Still, it’s better to go for eco products anyway - personally, I’ve never found anything to stop me sweating (oh, sorry, women gently glow rather than sweat don’t we?) so I’m happy with a deodorant.
Comment by Jean — September 1, 2006 @ 10:44 am
hi,
found your blog today. thought you may want to try, in response to the natural deodorant post, ‘Alba Botanica’ brand. It is the first natural one that i’ve liked, available at drugstore.com, whole foods, and merz apothecary (smallflower.com). But hey, if you have found your own home remedy with sodium bicarb, all the better, less packaging. I may give that idea a try.
:)
Comment by wendy — October 10, 2006 @ 11:54 pm
Thanks for the suggestion Wendy, I may well give Alba Botanica a try.
Comment by Tracy — October 11, 2006 @ 9:35 am